The law says you can't buy insurance across state lines. You can only buy from local companies. This site has full listings of all the insurers, state-by-state. Just confirm where you live and you will get access to all the leading insurers offering cheap auto insurance rates.
All it takes is you to to press "Start Quote" and you can start shopping around to find the most affordable rates for the level of cover you need. Given this is a completely free service and there's no obligation to buy, press "Start Quote" right now and get the quotes. You can't lose! You can only win!